Fri May 26, 2017 10:19 am
T6flyer wrote:KiwiZac wrote:Chris Brame wrote:I just hope they'll finally have some high-quality full-scale replica TBDs built.
I think I know a potential source for those...
Tempting, very tempting indeed. I for one would like us to build an Avenger as ground crewed on a British one for a few years during the 90s. For this and the other types required, they are a little thin on the ground over here in the UK, but having built the P-51s and P-40s for 'Red Tails', the Lysander for 'Allied' and two Spitfires for 'Dunkirk', I am sure we could rise to the challenge. Would make a pleasant change from building Spitfires, but then there is talk of a remake of the Battle of Britain film. Hurricanes and 109s....yes please!
Martin
Gateguards
Fri May 26, 2017 10:24 am
Jim MacDonald wrote:OD/NG,
I requested info from NASM several years ago about purchasing blueprints/engineering drawings of the TBD from them. They didn't have anything except for some photos and I believe some of Paul Matt's scale drawings. I've since been able to get Xerox copies of the maintenance manual, flight manual and engine manual, but NASM didn't even have those at the time I inquired about the blueprints.
I know that there are some scale RC plans for the TBD, but I have no idea how accurate they are. I wonder if it would be possible for Gateguards to use a combination of one of those sets of plans and photos to come up with some accurate replicas.
Maybe Lynn can chime in on whether anything new has come to light in the way of blueprints in the last couple of years. He has or had probably the most informative website out there on the TBD.
Mac
Fri May 26, 2017 10:31 am
Fri May 26, 2017 6:29 pm
lmritger wrote:Jim MacDonald wrote:OD/NG,
I requested info from NASM several years ago about purchasing blueprints/engineering drawings of the TBD from them. They didn't have anything except for some photos and I believe some of Paul Matt's scale drawings. I've since been able to get Xerox copies of the maintenance manual, flight manual and engine manual, but NASM didn't even have those at the time I inquired about the blueprints.
I know that there are some scale RC plans for the TBD, but I have no idea how accurate they are. I wonder if it would be possible for Gateguards to use a combination of one of those sets of plans and photos to come up with some accurate replicas.
Maybe Lynn can chime in on whether anything new has come to light in the way of blueprints in the last couple of years. He has or had probably the most informative website out there on the TBD.
Mac
Thanks for thinking of me Jim, but I've not seen anything other than the fantastic series of LIFE pics surface in the last 10-15 years. With that said, even those VT-6 shots (both the color ones and the later B/W series shot in November 1941) are a tremendously helpful resource, and now that the NHC has digitized almost all their NH series of photos in ridiculously high resolution, we have more than enough to get Martin and his team down the road on a passable TBD replica or six.
And that got me to thinking... could they be built with something like BT-13 main gear struts/wheels and stick a functional radial up front, to get them to look completely authentic as they taxi? Imagine how much that would add to the film!
Lynn
Fri May 26, 2017 6:56 pm
Might it be better, easier and cheaper to just plug some kind of electric engine on that capable of swinging a plastic or composite propeller of some sort?
Sat May 27, 2017 3:54 am
Stephan Wilkinson wrote:Might it be better, easier and cheaper to just plug some kind of electric engine on that capable of swinging a plastic or composite propeller of some sort?
As I recall, that's exactly what GategurdsUK did with the "Allied" Lysander.
Sat May 27, 2017 9:31 pm
Mon May 29, 2017 8:11 am
Mon May 29, 2017 9:20 am
JohnB wrote:It can't be a documentary or semi-documentary (witness Battle of Britain...which was pretty boring to anyone not interested in aircraft and which also had a rather passionless love story.
Wed May 31, 2017 3:22 pm
Wed May 31, 2017 3:32 pm
whistlingdeath77 wrote:I foresee another cgi movie leaving with the same feelings about " red tails" " Pearl Harbor" or " unbroken"
Wed May 31, 2017 3:45 pm
OD/NG wrote:whistlingdeath77 wrote:I foresee another cgi movie leaving with the same feelings about " red tails" " Pearl Harbor" or " unbroken"
I agree with you about "Red Tails" and "Pearl Harbor", both of which stunk with bad CGI. But, "Unbroken", really?
That movie had the best CGI I've ever seen. It was totally believable and added to the story line. If all movies had the CGI of "Unbroken", I would be totally happy.
Wed May 31, 2017 5:14 pm
whistlingdeath77 wrote:OD/NG wrote:whistlingdeath77 wrote:I foresee another cgi movie leaving with the same feelings about " red tails" " Pearl Harbor" or " unbroken"
I agree with you about "Red Tails" and "Pearl Harbor", both of which stunk with bad CGI. But, "Unbroken", really?
That movie had the best CGI I've ever seen. It was totally believable and added to the story line. If all movies had the CGI of "Unbroken", I would be totally happy.
Cgi meaning there was not a real flying b-24
Wed May 31, 2017 7:33 pm
Jim MacDonald wrote:OD/NG,
I requested info from NASM several years ago about purchasing blueprints/engineering drawings of the TBD from them. They didn't have anything except for some photos and I believe some of Paul Matt's scale drawings. I've since been able to get Xerox copies of the maintenance manual, flight manual and engine manual, but NASM didn't even have those at the time I inquired about the blueprints.
Mac
Thu Jun 01, 2017 9:42 am