WIXerGreg wrote:
I've seen and heard of quite a bit of these issues with Fram and other cheap filters in the automotive world too. The cartridges will collapse and the oil bypasses, the seams will split, or sometimes they'll even come apart and push the filter media through the engine. There were quite a few cases about ten years ago where Fram filters were coming apart on our Cummins trucks pushing filter media into the J jets that cool the pistons and causing piston damage. I expect sub zero 15w40 in a Cummins would be comparable to a cold aircraft engine.
Complicating matters even further is that the brand on the outside of the filter may have very little to do with the actual manufacturer. Fram, or whoever, will contract filters to a price point, and may switch makers and features like bypass valves and internal pleats without changing part numbers.
On the automotive side of things this has been a known thing for a while, and it's worthwhile to sacrifice a filter every once in a while to make sure the filter you are using is still well made.
This shouldn't be too much of an issue since everyone in aviation cuts open their filters at every oil change to inspect them (
right guys,
every time?) and you can note changes in construction.