reno wrote:
Thank you all very much, you've answered my question then some.....the knowledge shared here is second to none.
If i can ask another related question. did the hub stay standard on most types of the time using Hamilton Standard props with only the blade changing according to type and if so what types used this style hub same as the P47 shown (and corsair) ?
Thanks again
Ben
Okay Reno,
To get more info you may need to better identify the parts of the propeller according to their proper name. Let's look at this diagram, shall we?
As you can see, there is no part named "hub". The assembly of everthing but the blades is often referred to as the "hub". As you can see, there are lots of parts in there and lots of ways the engineer and applications people can alter it to where it may
look the same but they will not perform the same. From the external viewpoint, the hubs may all have identical appearance with the big seperations being number of blades, feathering ability, anti-icing equipment, and SAE spline size. Here is a generic applications chart.....
Hamilton Standard Propeller Applications (Partial List)
AIRCRAFT HUB OR
TYPE # BLADE #
B-29 24F60 6521
AVRO LANCASTER 23EX 6519
B-17 F & G 23E50 6477
B-25 ALL SERIES 23E50 6477
PBY CATALINA 23E50 6353
A-26 INVADER 23E50 6359
VENTURA 23E50 6477
B-25 ALL SERIES 23E50 6359A
MOSQUITO 23EX 6519
A-20 HAVOC/BOSTON 23E50 6353
AVENGER 23E50 6359
DAUNTLESS 23E50 6511
F6F HELLCAT 23E50 6541
P-51 24D50 K6523
CORSAIR 23E50 6525
C-97 24F60 6521-6
C-54 23E50 6507
C-47 23E50 6477
C-82 33E60 6491
C-69 CONSTELLATION 33E60 6491
OS2U KINGFISHER 2D20 - CW 6167
C-45/JRC 2D30 -CW 6167
C-87/JRB 2B20 - CW 6135
BT-13/15/SVN 2D30 - CW 6101
AT-6/SNJ/HARVARD 12D40 - CW 6101
NOTES:
1) CW = Counterweight type, all others Hydromatic
Externally, I would say that just about any 4 bladed, 60spline application will
LOOK like the p-47 application you ask of. That means even B29 and C97.....waaaaay bigger engines than the R2800 and vastly different applications so you KNOW they will not interchange exactly.
Here's a B29 on a 3350.....
Except for the alky tubes, it sure do
LOOK the same as those above doesn't it?!?!?
Does that make sense? I am no expert on these.....just collecting data and hoping to find you an answer. I would hazard a guess that the barrels and domes could indeed be close to the same for any 4F60 but certain details will change the part number so it would be difficult to tell. For instance, 2 identical parts in every way...dimension, alloy, heat treatment, etc EXCEPT surface treatment Cad plate vs. painted are often given different numbers. Would the
entire hub assembly be the same for a B29 as a P-47? I certainly doubt it. 80% of the parts might....but not all.
The unknown to me at this point is the blade shank size....If you look at the P47 and F4U-5 pics above by GrumpE, they are stenciled to use 6507 series blades. If you look at the chart listed above, 6507 is listed for a C54 and has an E size shank. An E size shank blade certainly takes a different barrel than an F shank blade. Was there a 4E60 hub? Beats me...I'll let those in the know fix that.