HarvardIV wrote:
For example, A.F. pilots are flying T-37s with less than 1000 hrs.
USAF student pilots fly the T-37 (and the T-6, the Americanized Piltaus PC-9) with less than *50* hours, and when I went through pilot training in '98 there were guys who flew the Tweet solo with less than *25* hours.
However, comparing what a USAF student is capable of in his early stages of training and what a civil-trained pilot can do at that same experience level is absolutely apples and oranges.
Stick with me as I go off on a tangent here...
USAF students in primary training "go to school" for 12 hours every day for a year -- it is their *life* while they are in primary training. On their (mandatory) 12 hours off they're sleeping for 8 of them and likely studying during the other 4. The depth of knowledge required of a USAF student is several times that of a new/recent private pilot, and every sortie from the very first flight is graded to Commercial standards.
I went to USAF pilot training as a Private Pilot with about 200 hours and complex and taildragger signoffs. When I compare the airmanship and knowledge level I had as a Private Pilot to the levels required when a USAF student, there is simply no comparison. I was a *much* better pilot as a USAF student, due directly to the high academic and airmanship standard that I had to live up to. When was the last time you had to state an emergency procedure out of the POH word-for-word at the drop of the hat? USAF students have to do that...and if they can't do it perfectly (no "um" or stumbling over words) they fail the flight or don't get to fly that day at all. When was the last time that you had to sit down with a blank sheet of paper and recite all the operations limits of your aircraft and engine number-for-number perfectly? Again, this is a daily task for USAF students. The standards they have to live up to are WAY higher than what was ever required out of me as a civil pilot.
So, back to the topic at hand. USAF students fly jets from day one, and the training program is mighty intense. Even then, it takes about 300 hours total to even become a basically-trained pilot in a Major Weapon System (C-17, F-15...anything not a trainer). They're not "turned loose with the keys to the jet" until after 2 years and 300+ hours of intense training.
I'm not putting down civil pilots in any way, because certainly military jocks aren't the end-all, be-all of aviators (and there are plenty that really suck!). I absolutely think that civil-trained pilots can be just as good as military trained pilots. However, if you look at a civilian pilot with 300 hours and a military pilot with 300 hours you will see a clear difference in skill set.
So, while I agree that 1,000 hours may be too much for a jet LOA, I don't agree that civilian pilots should get turned loose in jets at the same hourly experience level as military pilots (who have been flying jets to a very high airmanship standard since day one).