Spin/unusual attitude training is a great idea, and something every pilot should do.
However, it's important to recognize what spin training courses are...they are just an introduction to spins. Being proficient in spin recovery really means two things: 1) being comfortable enough in unfamiliar attitudes that you can think logically and carefully about how the recovery should be effected, and 2) being familiar with the spin characteristics of your aircraft.
Only experience can satisfy #1; I think it takes people a good 25-50 hours of aerobatics before they get where they can think calmly no matter what attitude the airplane is in.
Being familiar with your specific aircraft is important and often understated. A lot of spin training is given in Citabria derivatives, which are very nice spinning aircraft (upright..after 2 turns most Decathlons wrap up fast in inverted spins and can take several additional turns to recover).
However, the noises and view and buffeting and control response while spinning a Decathlon is very different from a 172. I've seen people get perfectly comfortable spinning a Citabria and then freak out in a 172 spin the next day. Some aircraft - like a Chipmunk without strakes - require application of controls in reverse order (i.e. stick forward first, then rudder) and will not recover if you just kick opposite rudder and center the stick. Also, whereas a Decathlon will break cleanly into a spin, it is very easy to slide a Cessna into a spiral dive and think you are spinning...but then realize that the ASI is indicating 180!
I think some of the best training for spin recovery - or I should say spin avoidance - is to get very proficient "walking" the aircraft around with the rudders while at a high AOA/edge of a stall.
|