mrhenniger wrote:
Dan Johnson II wrote:
Needless to say in true Hollywood fashion, they took what was a great story and overdramatized it to the point of overkill.
True... The only thing in common between the movie and reality was the title. However... if you set aside the name it is a fairly decent representation of what bomber crews faced on each mission, most just didn't have all of that stuff happen on just one mission. Mid-air collisions and near collisions in bomber streams were not unusual. The nose of a plane being blown off did happen. The stress and fear leading to people going off the deep end did happen. The movie is fairly good and true to reality of life for a bomber crew, just not the Mephis Belle crew.
Anyone agree? I am not a historian, just a hobbiest historian.
Mike
I think it depends on who you ask. A 301st BG, 15th AF B17 tail gunner that I know, thought it was great. He'd survived being shot down and pinned in the tail, riding it all the way down and surviving.
I talked to some 8th AF vets, including a 91st BG B17 pilot who also was shot down and made a POW. He hated it. One of the comments made was that no crew would act as childish as the Belle crew did in the movie. They were way too dependent on each other to being doing those kinds of things in flight.
That was his opinion of course but since he'd been there, done that, it kind of stuck with me.
Dan