Ken wrote:
TonyM wrote:
if I remember correctly, the 10 March mishap followed a low-level, long-range over-water flight in preparation for the mission.
I have no doubt, Tony, that you are correct. My earlier comment regarded a poster who said (paraphrased) that he knew that they trained "on the edge" but didn't realize that such training actually caused accidents. My point was that, regardless of how "on the edge" the Joyce mission that day may have been, he most likely executed a normal landing at Ellington, suffered a shimmy damper failure and collapsed his nose gear ... damaging, but hardly the result of aggressive training ... that could have happened upon landing from a vanilla sight-seeing flight. The Crack Up #2, stall on takeoff, can most definitely be contributed to "training on the edge" ... and that's exactly what they were doing to cause the wreck.
Sorry if it seems like splitting hairs, I just felt as if the first comment sensationalized an accident simply because it occurred to a Doolittle crew during their training time.
Ken
No problem Ken. Thanks for the feed back.
You're right, the shimmy dampner would have failed eventually--it just happened to fail after the practice mission.
The second mishap is very intersting from the history point of view. Stall at 20 feet agl. No one hurt. Plane broken. Must have been quite a ride, albeit a short one.
Thanks to all for the comments.